Hello dear
Welcome To New York New York Pizza
**OUR STORY**Welcome to New York New York Pizza, where authentic flavors meet warm hospitality in the heart of Tampa's vibrant Ybor City. Our journey began with a passion for crafting pizzas that evoke the spirit of New York City—each slice is a celebration of quality ingredients and culinary tradition. Customers rave about our signature Grandma pizza and delectable white pizza, with flavors that resonate beyond the plate. The attentive staff enhances your experience, ensuring each visit feels like coming home. Here, every dish—from our crispy fried appetizers to mouthwatering subs—reflects our commitment to outstanding taste and a welcoming atmosphere. Join us and discover why we’re a beloved staple in the community!
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Fried Mozzarella
Marinara Sauce
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
About
New York New York Pizza
Welcome to New York New York Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the vibrant heart of Ybor City, Tampa. Located at 1512 E 7th Ave, this establishment is dedicated to serving authentic New York-style pizza that transports you straight to the bustling streets of the Big Apple.
From the moment you step inside, you're enveloped in a warm ambiance, paired with the irresistible aroma of freshly baked pizzas wafting from the oven. The love and care that goes into each dish is palpable, as noted by customers who rave about their unforgettable experiences. Many have likened this haven of flavor to the best pizzerias in New York, and they firmly advocate it as a must-visit destination for both locals and visitors alike.
- Signature Pizzas: Their pizza selections are a highlight, featuring crispy crusts and vibrant toppings. The grandma pizza and white pizza are fan favorites, cherished for their bold flavors.
- Satisfying Portions: Guests are often delighted by the generous sizes of the slices, making them perfect for sharing or indulging solo.
- Diverse Menu: Besides pizza, New York New York Pizza offers a variety of delectable options, including Stromboli, freshly made salads, and hearty baked pasta dishes like meat lasagna and baked ziti.
Customer feedback consistently reflects high satisfaction. Raeann Butler shared her delight with the large, flavorful slices, noting the attentive service and the absence of post-meal discomfort—truly a win for those with sensitive stomachs. Similarly, Exilas Alex Delphin praised both the warm atmosphere and the staff's commitment to creating memorable dining experiences, particularly highlighting their ability to make special occasions unforgettable.
As you dive into the menu, the baked pasta options provide an enticing alternative for when you're craving something beyond pizza. Each dish is crafted with quality ingredients that complement the rich flavors, ensuring every bite is a true delight. The salads also offer a fresh and crunchy accompaniment to your meal, balancing the richness of the pizza beautifully.
With a reputation for friendly service and a bustling environment, customers often find the experience at New York New York Pizza to be as satisfying as the food itself. Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice or planning a special occasion, you're bound to leave with a happy stomach and a smile.
For a slice of culinary heaven in Tampa, look no further than New York New York Pizza. Make your way to 1512 E 7th Ave, or give them a call at +1 813-248-1845 to discover the pizza that everyone's been raving about.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This place was amazing. Prices were competitive & pizza was so delicious. We got the grandma pizza, white pizza, & pepperoni. The staff was kind & attentive. The place was clean. I have an extremely sensitive stomach when it comes to rich or greasy food & I ate both my slices (which were pretty large) && didn’t have any stomach issues all night. Looking forward to visiting Ybor again just to eat this pizza!! ”
“ Absolutely love Eddie & Sam's Pizza! As a former New Yorker, I can confidently say it’s better than any pizza I had back in NYC. The flavor is incredible truly delicious and satisfying. The place was buzzing with people lining up to get their hands on a slice, and the fast, automated checkout made the experience even better. Can’t wait to go back! ”
“ Absolutely must eat here if you're in the area! The pizza is fantastic! The slices are enormous and delicious! We tried 4 different pizzas and they were all incredible. Teri and Bobby, our servers, were keeping an eye on us, always refilling our drinks and attending us. I plan on returning to try more food. This is a staple in Tampa for a reason!!! ”
“ I would love to give a special shout out to the staff and management team for "The Greatest Experience" I've had at a pizza restaurant... New York New York Pizza in Ybor City, Tampa, was by far the best I've had in years... The minute you walk in, you can feel and smell the love in the pizza pit oven... The love we got from the Lexx who served us was the highlight" of our dining experience... She explained the menu and gave her suggestions on popular hot items and her favorite menu choice... My friend was celebrating his birthday, and she made sure his birthday was unforgettable, wishing him many more years of a rich, youthful life of crazy joy... A huge shout out to the master pizza chef for the creation of pizza heaven... Thank you all for the wonderful dining experience.. From one Lexx to the other Lexx, you are truly the best in the industry... ”
“ I absolutely love New York, New York Pizza every time I visit! From their wings to their pizza, everything is consistently delicious—you really can’t go wrong. In my opinion, it’s the best pizza in Tampa, and I’ve never had a bad experience. The quality, flavor, and service always keep me coming back. Keep serving up your amazing food! ”
“ Exceptional Service from Miguel! I’ve been visiting New York New York Pizza regularly, and it’s all thanks to Miguel! From the very first time he served me, he created such a welcoming and friendly atmosphere that I’ve found myself coming back every few days. His great attitude, attentiveness, and genuine hospitality make every visit enjoyable. It’s clear that Miguel truly values his customers, and his service is a big reason why this place has such a great vibe. If you’re looking for delicious pizza with top-notch service, make sure to stop by and ask for Miguel—you won’t be disappointed! ”
“ Was down closing some contracts in south Tampa near Ybor when I smelled this amazing scent. Next thing I know I’m grabbing slices of pizza from this spot that’s has the BEST PIZZA I’ve eaten in all my years. I don’t want to sound arrogant being from Chicago but I know a Great slice of pizza and this was definitely the greatest 4 slices I’ve ever eaten!! The dough light crispy & the sauce definitely the best house made sauce. I had 2 pepperoni & 2 fettuccine slices. My regret when I woke up this morning was me not having a slice for breakfast!! Please Dave Portnoy go to this place! It’s a heavenly slice of New York in a small nook of big City Tampa. ”
“ Thank you all for an amazing lunch. The hospitality, service, and food were outstanding. We had Eggplant Parmesan and also a Chicken Alfredo Pizza. I have been several times and always have had an awesome experience and today I brought a friend in for lunch and it was his first time and wanted to say Thank you and enjoyed lunch very much. See you soon and once again Thank you all , Sincerely Chris. ”